Party games
Would You Rather for Groups: 12 Questions, 56 More in Pick a Side
This list gives you twelve would you rather questions for groups, from silly to deep. Each one is a simple choice that forces everyone to pick a side, so the whole room joins in within seconds.
Silly and awkward starters
- Would you rather have a pet hamster that gives advice or a parrot that gossips?
- Would you rather be the fastest person in a room of turtles or the slowest in a room of cheetahs?
- Would you rather have a voice like a cartoon or a face like a statue?
- Would you rather send a text to the wrong group or read a message meant for someone else?
- Would you rather give a speech with no notes or sing one with no lyrics?
- Would you rather be dragged onto the dance floor or left alone in the corner?
Cozy and deep rounds
- Would you rather have a quiet weekend at home or a loud weekend in a new city?
- Would you rather share one blanket forever or have two blankets that never match?
- Would you rather keep every memory or forget every regret?
- Would you rather be loved for what you do or for who you are?
- Would you rather be honest and hurt someone or kind and hide the truth?
- Would you rather be known for kindness or for courage?
Start with the silly questions when the room is still warming up. Save the cozy and deep ones for the second half of the night, when people have laughed together and trust each other enough to explain their choice honestly.
Why would you rather works in groups
A would you rather question asks for a choice, not a speech. Even the shyest person in the room can pick a side in one second, and that small move is enough to start the talk. Once people are on a side, they want to defend it. That is where the best answers come from, because nobody is giving a prepared opinion. They are reacting to the people around them.
Keep the rounds short. Read the question, let the room choose, ask two people for their reason, and move on. If a question splits the group evenly, that is a good sign. If everyone lands on the same side, change the second option next time so the choice feels real.
Cards from Pick a Side
Pick a Side is the deck built for this format. Every card gives two options, and everyone has to choose one out loud. These four come from Tonight Deck.
- Pick a Side Pizza curse: every slice is cold forever, or every topping is chosen by someone else…
- Pick a Side Love confession: say it over a loudspeaker, or let your partner whisper it…
- Pick a Side Dessert: your favorite always tastes new, or every new dessert tastes like home…
- Pick a Side Friendship: hear a hard truth right away, or get the perfect gentle wording a week later…
That deck has 56 more. Scratch them in Tonight Deck.
Which mood for which moment
| Mood | Best time | Why it works |
|---|---|---|
| Silly | Warm-up | Nobody has to be serious yet |
| Awkward | A loud room | Shared cringe builds quick trust |
| Cozy | Late evening | Gentle choices invite soft answers |
| Deep | The last round | People have earned the honest version |
For more games, try party games for adults or games to play with friends on one phone. Both work well after a round of choices, when the room is ready to move.
FAQ
How do I keep a would you rather round fair?
Read both options aloud, then ask why only after everyone has chosen. Tonight Deck's Pick a Side cards show both options on screen for the whole room.
How many would you rather questions do we need for a party?
Six to ten is enough for one night. Start silly and build up, and let the Pick a Side deck in Tonight Deck cover the rest.
Is there an app that picks the question for you?
Yes. Tonight Deck shows a Pick a Side card with both options, so nobody has to invent them.
What if nobody wants to pick a side?
Let people stay in the middle and explain their reasons. A reluctant answer still counts, and the Pick a Side deck in Tonight Deck has more to choose from.
